How do I know whether a parking problem is caused by limited supply or poor management?

A parking problem is not always a parking-shortage problem. Drivers may struggle to find spaces even when capacity exists nearby because the available parking is poorly allocated, difficult to locate, priced incorrectly, reserved for the wrong users, or underused during the periods when demand is highest. The first step is to understand how the system actually performs. A parking study can evaluate occupancy, turnover, duration, peak demand, user patterns, pricing, access, nearby facilities, and operational constraints. That helps distinguish a true capacity gap from a management problem. The Federal Highway Administration guidance on active parking management explains that parking facilities can be managed dynamically to improve utilization, influence travel decisions, reduce circling, and support traffic flow.

Should we build more parking, or make better use of the parking we already have?

Building more parking is not always the best first answer. Before adding capacity, it is useful to understand whether the existing supply can perform better through improved allocation, shared use, pricing, signage, technology, operational changes, or transportation-demand strategies. A planning study can help determine where parking is constrained, where spaces are underused, how demand changes by time and user group, and whether a new facility is justified. The goal is to invest in the solution that solves the actual problem rather than defaulting to the most expensive option. The U.S. Department of Transportation overview of parking reforms explains that parking reforms can help use existing supply more efficiently and better balance parking supply and demand.

What information should be reviewed before deciding whether a new parking garage is needed?

Before committing to a new parking facility, it is useful to evaluate: Existing parking supply and occupancy Peak demand by time, day, and user group Turnover and parking duration Nearby public and private parking resources Shared-parking opportunities Pricing and permit policies Expected development, land-use, and mobility changes Transportation-demand-management opportunities Capital costs, operating expenses, and projected revenues The value of the land and alternative uses for the site The right answer may be a new facility, a smaller facility, a phased strategy, or operational improvements that delay or reduce the need for new construction.

What does it mean to “right-size” parking?

Building more parking is not always the best first answer. Before adding capacity, it is useful to understand whether the existing supply can perform better through improved allocation, shared use, pricing, signage, technology, operational changes, or transportation-demand strategies. A planning study can help determine where parking is constrained, where spaces are underused, how demand changes by time and user group, and whether a new facility is justified. The goal is to invest in the solution that solves the actual problem rather than defaulting to the most expensive option. The U.S. Department of Transportation overview of parking reforms explains that parking reforms can help use existing supply more efficiently and better balance parking supply and demand.

Can shared parking reduce the need to build more spaces?

In some cases, yes. Shared parking can reduce the need for dedicated spaces when different users or land uses generate peak demand at different times. For example, an office, restaurant, residential development, event venue, or retail use may not need its maximum parking supply at the same time of day. A shared-parking analysis evaluates whether existing or planned spaces can serve more than one user group without creating unacceptable conflicts. The appropriate strategy depends on location, operating hours, walking distances, access arrangements, peak periods, and the reliability of the available supply.

When should a parking and mobility study be updated?

There is no single update schedule that fits every property or community. A parking and mobility study should be revisited when the conditions shaping demand have changed enough that older assumptions may no longer support good decisions. Triggers may include major development, changing land uses, new transit service, altered work patterns, new event activity, recurring parking complaints, changing curb demand, updated pricing, new mobility options, or a major capital-investment decision. The point is not to update a study for the sake of producing another report. It is to make sure the next decision is based on current conditions rather than an outdated picture of how people move.

How can parking pricing improve access?

Parking pricing can be used as a management tool, not simply as a revenue source. When parking demand is high, pricing can encourage turnover, improve availability, influence where people park, and support more efficient use of limited spaces. The right strategy depends on the location and the goal. Some communities use fixed rates. Others use variable or escalating prices based on demand, time, or duration. The Federal Highway Administration primer on parking pricing explains that pricing can help manage parking supply, improve the experience for drivers who continue to park, reduce congestion, and improve access.

What is performance-based parking pricing?

Performance-based parking pricing adjusts rates to help achieve a defined parking-management goal, such as maintaining availability in high-demand areas or encouraging better use of underused spaces nearby. Rather than charging the same amount in every location at every time, the strategy can use variable prices or escalating prices to respond more effectively to demand. The Federal Highway Administration parking-pricing primer explains the distinction between free or fixed-rate parking and performance-based approaches.

What is a parking financial feasibility study?

A parking financial feasibility study evaluates whether a proposed parking investment, operating strategy, or asset decision is financially supportable. Depending on the project, the analysis may consider market conditions, parking demand, price sensitivity, projected revenues, operating expenses, capital costs, financing assumptions, and potential funding gaps. The goal is to give owners, developers, public agencies, and financial stakeholders a clearer understanding of the risks, assumptions, and tradeoffs before a major commitment is made.

When should a parking financial feasibility study be performed?

A parking financial feasibility study may be useful before: Developing a new parking facility Financing or refinancing a parking asset Acquiring a property with paid parking Changing parking prices or permit structures Evaluating a public-private partnership Considering parking-system monetization Planning a major redevelopment or mixed-use project Assessing whether expected revenues can support operating and capital needs The earlier the assumptions are tested, the more flexibility the project team has to adjust the strategy before decisions become expensive to unwind.

Why has curb management become more important?

The curb is no longer used only for parking. It may also need to support commercial deliveries, passenger pick-up and drop-off, transit, ride-app activity, accessible access, bicycle and scooter parking, dining, loading, and other public uses. When multiple users compete for the same limited space, unmanaged curb activity can contribute to congestion, safety concerns, double parking, access problems, and frustration for local businesses and visitors. The U.S. Department of Transportation overview of parking and curb management explains that effective strategies coordinate parking, traffic, transit, pedestrian, and micromobility needs to improve performance and curb productivity.

What should a curb management study evaluate?

A curb management study should begin with a clear understanding of how curb space is currently allocated and used. Depending on the location, the review may consider parking, loading, deliveries, passenger pick-up and drop-off, ride-app activity, transit, accessible access, bicycle and scooter activity, enforcement, time-of-day patterns, nearby off-street resources, and the needs of local businesses and residents. The Federal Highway Administration Curbside Inventory Report provides guidance for assessing, gathering, and analyzing curbside inventory information.

Can curb management reduce congestion and improve safety?

Yes. Effective curb management can help reduce conflicts, improve access, and make limited curb space work more efficiently. The right strategy may include clearer allocations, loading zones, pick-up and drop-off areas, pricing, reservations, enforcement, nearby off-street alternatives, technology, or time-based rules that reflect how demand changes throughout the day. The U.S. Department of Transportation parking and curb management overview explains that these strategies can reduce congestion, improve safety, increase parking capacity, decrease the time spent searching for spaces, and optimize curb productivity.

How should a community decide which curb uses take priority?

There is no universal curb allocation that works for every street, district, airport, campus, or commercial area. The right priorities depend on the location, surrounding land uses, safety needs, business activity, pedestrian volumes, transit service, delivery demand, accessibility requirements, community goals, and how conditions change throughout the day. A useful curb-management process combines data with stakeholder input. The goal is not to give every user the same amount of space. It is to allocate limited curb space in a way that supports the most important outcomes for that location.

What is transportation demand management, and how does it relate to parking planning?

Transportation demand management, often called TDM, is a set of strategies intended to give travelers more effective choices about how, when, and where they travel. Depending on the setting, TDM may include transit, walking, biking, shared mobility, carpooling, parking pricing, permit strategies, flexible work arrangements, or information that helps people make different travel decisions. TDM matters in parking planning because the number of spaces needed is influenced by how people travel. The Federal Highway Administration guidance on transportation demand management describes TDM as a strategy for maximizing traveler choices and improving travel reliability.

Can parking and curb strategies support local businesses?

Yes. Parking and curb strategies can support local businesses when they improve access for customers, deliveries, employees, visitors, and service providers. The right strategy may involve turnover, short-term parking, loading zones, pick-up and drop-off areas, pricing, wayfinding, enforcement, or nearby off-street alternatives. The goal is not simply to increase the number of spaces. It is to make access work better for the people and businesses the area needs to serve.

What information should I gather before requesting a parking or mobility study?

Useful information may include: The location, property type, district, campus, or study area Existing parking supply and any known capacity concerns Recurring complaints or operational issues Current pricing, permit, and enforcement policies Known curbside conflicts involving deliveries, loading, or pick-up and drop-off activity Planned development, redevelopment, or land-use changes Available occupancy, transaction, revenue, expense, or utilization data Community, stakeholder, budget, and schedule considerations You do not need to have every answer before starting the conversation. The available information helps define the right study scope and identify where closer analysis may provide the most value.

Walker Parking and Mobility Services

See the pattern before you choose the path.

Travel patterns shift. Communities grow. Priorities compete. The hardest mobility decisions are often the ones shaped by conditions that are not immediately obvious. Walker helps you understand how people move, identify what others may miss, and bring clarity to the tradeoffs so you can make better planning decisions and move forward with confidence.

Learn More About Curb Management Learn More About Data Science & Analytics Learn More About Financial Feasibility Learn More About Parking Planning

See the pattern before you choose the path.

Questions about Planning & Mobility